The Costs and Benefits of Animal Experiments
*** Read the reviews ***
*** Follow the debate ***
Are animal experiments justified? A new book published by Palgrave Macmillan sheds new light on one of the greatest controversies in animal ethics.
Few ethical issues create as much controversy as invasive experiments on animals. Some scientists claim they are essential for combating major human diseases, or detecting human toxins. Others claim the contrary, backed by thousands of patients harmed by pharmaceuticals developed using animal tests. Some claim all experiments are conducted humanely, to high scientific standards. Yet, a wealth of studies have recently revealed that laboratory animals suffer significant stress, which may distort experimental results.
Where, then, does the truth lie? How useful are such experiments in advancing human healthcare? How much do animals suffer as a result? And do students really need to dissect or experiment on animals? What are the effects on their attitudes towards them?
In The Costs and Benefits of Animal Experiments, bioethicist and veterinarian Dr. Andrew Knight presents more than a decade of ground-breaking scientific research, analysis and experience to provide evidence-based answers to a key question: is animal experimentation ethically justifiable?
By analysing large numbers of animal experiments selected randomly — the ‘gold standard’ when assessing biomedical research, and reviewing over 500 scientific publications, Knight is able to offer unprecedented insights into the contributions of animal experimentation to human healthcare, and the extent to which laboratory animals suffer. He provides the most recent evidence-based estimations of laboratory animal use globally and in major world regions, and reviews the types of procedures animals are subjected to and their level of invasiveness.
“When considering costs and benefits overall”, he states, “one cannot reasonably conclude that the benefits accruing to human patients or consumers, or to those motivated by scientific curiosity or profit, exceed the costs incurred by animals subjected to scientific procedures. On the contrary, the evidence indicates that actual human benefit is rarely – if ever – sufficient to justify such costs.”
Knight concludes with an overview of key regulations governing animal experimentation within Europe and North America, and proposes a set of policy reforms to facilitate increased implementation of alternative research and testing strategies. He concludes that,
“Rigorous implementation of policies such as these would restore to animal research the balance between human and animal interests expected by society, intended by legislation, and demanded by detailed ethical review.”
1 - Introduction
PART I: ANIMAL COSTS
2 - Global Laboratory Animal Use
3 - Types of Laboratory Animal Use
4 - Impacts on Laboratory Animals
PART II: HUMAN BENEFITS
5 - Human Clinical Utility of Animal Models
6 - Human Toxicological Utility of Animal Models
7 - Factors Limiting the Human Utility of Animal Models
PART III: ALTERNATIVE STRATEGIES
8 - Non-Animal Research and Testing Methodologies
9 - Reduction and Refinement of Laboratory Animal Use
PART IV: EDUCATIONAL ANIMAL USE AND STUDENT IMPACTS
10 - Educational Animal Use
11 - Effects of Harmful Animal Use on Students
PART V: CONCLUSIONS AND POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS
12 - The Costs and Benefits of Animal Experimentation
13 - Regulatory Developments and Policy Recommendations
Email: reviews (at) palgrave.com
North America: http://us.macmillan.com/thecostsandbenefitsofanimalexperiments/AndrewKnight
• In recent years laboratory animal numbers have steadily risen globally and in many individual countries, including the UK, US and others. The major causes are increased use of genetically-modified animals and the implementation of historically unprecedented large-scale chemical testing programmes within Europe and the US.
• At the core of almost all regulations governing laboratory animal use is the requirement that animal ethics committees conduct a cost/benefit analysis to ensure that the expected benefits of such research exceed its likely costs. Humans are the major beneficiaries, and animals incur the major costs. The required cost/benefit analysis normally relies on educated guesses or assumptions about human benefit and animal suffering. However, strong scientific evidence has recently demonstrated that these assumptions are often fundamentally flawed. This book is the first to comprehensively review this evidence.
• The Costs and Benefits of Animal Experiments is the third publication in the Palgrave Macmillan Series on Animal Ethics. The Series provides a range of key introductory and advanced texts that map out ethical positions on animal issues. It is expected to play a major role in establishing the emerging field of animal ethics. Series information: www.oxfordanimalethics.com/what-we-do/publication/animal-ethics-book-series/ and www.palgrave.com/products/Series.aspx?s=PMAES.
• The Palgrave Macmillan Series on Animal Ethics is an initiative of the Oxford Centre for Animal Ethics (www.OxfordAnimalEthics.com). The latter is an international centre of excellence dedicated to pioneering ethical perspectives on animals through academic research, teaching, and publication.
• Australian-British animal ethicist Dr. Andrew Knight is a European Veterinary Specialist in Welfare Science, Ethics and Law, and a Fellow of the Oxford Centre for Animal Ethics. He has published a suite of studies examining the contribution of animal experiments to human healthcare, which have attracted a series of awards at international scientific conferences. These studies also formed the basis for his 2010 PhD, which appears to be the first of its kind. When not writing, travelling or presenting Dr Knight practices veterinary medicine in London.